Human Behaviour and Its Impact on Crisis

One constant through time is crisis, whether it be political, professional, or personal. While no one wants to experience a crisis, it is inevitable. That said, our responses are fully under our control. The examination of the history of crisis leaves us with many lessons learned based on the successes and failures of others.

Any discussion about crisis management should be framed by a definition that solidifies common language. I tend to use the British Standard that states:

An abnormal and unstable situation that threatens the organisation’s strategic objectives, reputation, or viability, and which requires a response beyond business as usual.

I am the owner and founder of a crisis management advisory company. Most days I am supporting medium to large organisations before, during and after a crisis. One of the key ingredients to successful navigation during a crisis is preparation and planning. These table stakes include developing a dedicated crisis management program that is regularly exercised. That said, one recurring observation is the impact of human behavior on the outcome of a crisis regardless of industry. I offer the following five (5) human behaviors as areas where an organisation either thrives or flounders during a crisis:

  1. PARALYSIS BY ANALYSIS

Day-to-day business allows us the luxury of time to gather maximum information and perform analysis before making a decision. Unfortunately, crisis drives us to make decisions quickly often with imperfect information. Crisis decisions also tend to center around riskier issues making crisis management team (CMT) members want even more time than normal to arrive at a decision. CMT members that adapt their decision-making style and accept more risk while in crisis mode will not fall prey to this paralysis pitfall.

There is often a temptation to wait a situation out, hoping that an issue will go away. This rarely works and the lost time often amplifies the gravity of the crisis. This should not be confused with a conscious decision not to conduct a certain action right away. There may be very valid reasons for waiting to perform a certain action. This is fine if it was a conscious and deliberate decision and not wishful thinking driving the inaction.

  1. GROUP THINK

I have been lucky enough to work for some great leaders who were also charismatic. Everybody on the team loved them and they always knew what to do! There are corporate cultures where it is frowned upon or career limiting to disagree with any leader further up the organisational ladder.  If you are that awesome leader or work in the aforementioned culture, you must be wary of group think. A leader or senior individual raises an idea and instantly it is the greatest thought ever. While it might feel good to have your team always agree with all your ideas, this atmosphere agitates directly against creative thought which is often needed to guide an organisation out of crisis. It is imperative that all CMT members have a voice and feel 100% comfortable tabling a new idea or questioning something that someone else has put forward. This challenge function is critical in ensuring an organisation is using its “collective brain” to resolve an issue.

A quick caveat on the challenge function – this is not an invitation towards endless debate or fiercely advocating a position. When there is time and opportunity, a CMT should invite healthy cognitive debate but as deadlines loom, it is imperative to eventually “pull the trigger” and move forward with a decided course of action.

  1. BLAME GAME

When an organisation finds itself in crisis mode, it is often tempting to seek who or what department is at fault. Leaders and departments should be held accountable for their actions and decisions yet determining root cause or punitive actions during the crisis is counter-productive unless they are necessary to inform future decisions within that crisis.

This issue can also raise its ugly head when a novel approach that was put forward by a CMT member was trialed but with negative results. Again, directing blame towards this team member risks alienating them for the remainder of the crisis and destroys any psychological safety that may have existed within the team. At the end of the day, the crisis team leader is accountable for the team’s decisions, not the members themselves.

Finally, team leaders need to understand there are going to be mistakes, especially due to the time compression and imperfect information available when making decisions. It is important to understand that a mistake has been made but beating oneself up about it risks distracting everyone from the task at hand – moving the organisation out of crisis. There will be plenty of time during the after action or hotwash to discuss mistakes and remediations for future crises.

  1. FOLLOWERSHIP

When building your crisis management team, you want your best leaders from your various organisational departments. What happens when you put most of your best leaders in one room? Assuming there is a crisis management plan that stipulates a crisis management team leader to guide the team, it is not always comfortable for some leaders to not be “in charge”. Teams that thrive through crisis are blessed with leaders who can bring their “A” game as a crisis team member by following the designated leader and providing their full support. Followership is not blindly following a leader. A good follower is bringing their perspectives towards creative solutions to the crisis and challenging other perspectives. That said, once a CMT has decided on a direction, a good follower is 100% committed to supporting that decision, especially if it was not a direction that they thought the team should be heading.

  1. LEADERSHIP

I am often asked what the secret is to successfully navigating a crisis. I used to talk about structuring a crisis management program, supported by strong planning and training. These are still truths today, but the best response is “leadership under stress”. If your organisation has strong leaders that are comfortable with sudden change, can make time compressed decisions and fully harness the collective mind of the CMT, they are already far more resilient. It might not be unicorns and rainbows when crisis strikes, but the organisation will spend less time in crisis mode, mitigating the impact of the crisis.

When developing crisis team leader candidates for a CMT, there is a natural temptation to select the most senior or ranked person for this role. There are different styles of leadership, and some great leaders may not be the best fit to lead during crisis. It is critical that crisis leaders be selected against the above noted criteria, trained for the role with realistic scenarios and most importantly enjoy the trust of their organisation during a crisis.

Crisis management is crisis leadership!

As previously mentioned, resilient organisations should have strong crisis management programs, supported by planning and training. This should always be the target, yet many organisations’ crisis management programs mature at varying rates. Whether your organisation enjoys the best crisis management program ever conceived or struggles with a nascent capability, these five (5) human behaviors are easy targets for an organisation. Awareness of the pitfalls and desired traits will always lead to more positive outcomes during crisis.

**This article is available for download.  It was also posted to the Institute of Strategic Risk Management website as Canadian Chapter content.**

Share This

Comments are closed.

Recent Posts

Crisis leadership – seizing the golden hour!

Winning strategies for effective crisis management

A recent Netflix series documented Sir Winston Churchill, the United Kingdom’s Prime Minister who guided his nation through the global crisis of the Second World War. While controversial, his leadership brought many together in the fight against fascism and changed the world we live in today. What made him successful in the face of an overwhelming enemy and difficult geo-political terrain? The documentary did not provide enough detail in how Churchill organised himself to clearly state whether he was lucky or did he follow crisis management best practises to victory. What is clear, is that crisis defined his legacy as a leader. Today, crisis still defines how leaders and organisations are perceived.

If Covid taught us anything as a society, it is that crisis is inevitable, and it is highly likely we will not be offered the luxury of deciding when calamity strikes. After a 35+ year career in public and private sector roles, my current professional life has me focused on supporting organisations in preparing for and responding to crisis. The following keys to successful crisis management are a collection of what I have seen as best practises gleaned from working with my clients.

Read More »
Facet5 psychometric tool

Facet5 – what are and why we use psychometric assessment tools

Unlocking Leadership Potential with Facet5: A Revolution in Psychometric Insight
In the fast-paced, interconnected world of modern business, understanding the complexities of leadership has become a critical success factor. Leaders must navigate intricate team dynamics, drive innovation, and inspire others—all while maintaining a keen self-awareness of their own strengths, preferences, and challenges. Enter Facet5, the psychometric tool that redefines the way we evaluate and enhance leadership potential. Facet5 has been the preferred choice for many senior leaders across Europe, North America, and Canada, widely recognized for its depth, versatility, and practical application.
What Sets Facet5 Apart?
At its core, Facet5 is rooted in the “Big Five” personality model, one of the most scientifically validated frameworks for understanding human behavior. While many tools rely on generic outputs or lack depth, Facet5 dives into the nuances of personality, offering a precise, evidence-based, and actionable framework for self-awareness.
Unlike traditional psychometric tools that can feel static and overly academic, Facet5 strikes a great balance between scientific rigor and business relevance. Its detailed yet intuitive profile enables individuals to explore their personality traits across five core dimensions: Will, Energy, Affection, Control, and Emotionality. These dimensions go beyond broad categorizations, providing insights into how leaders approach challenges, interact with others, and respond under pressure.

Practical Applications for Senior Leaders
For senior leaders, self-awareness is more than a buzzword; it is the cornerstone of effective leadership. The demands of C-suite and executive roles require a finely tuned understanding of how personal behavior influences team performance, organizational culture, and strategic outcomes. Facet5 excels in this arena, offering senior leaders a roadmap for growth that is as insightful as it is actionable.

Building Self-Awareness and Resilience
Facet5 helps leaders uncover their innate tendencies, from how they assert themselves in decision-making to how they manage stress and foster collaboration. In doing so, it equips them with the tools to embrace their strengths while mitigating potential blind spots. A senior leader at a multinational corporation shared, “Facet5 gave me the language and framework to truly understand my leadership style. It was like holding up a mirror to my professional self, with clarity I’d never experienced before.”
Cultural Relevance and Adaptability
Facet5 is particularly adept at accommodating the cultural nuances of leadership across international organizations and project delivery alliances that involve multiple partners. With organizations increasingly embracing global teams, leaders must navigate diverse perspectives and working styles. Facet5’s versatility ensures that its insights remain culturally sensitive and applicable, making it a trusted tool in cross-border leadership development.
Unlocking Collective Potential
Beyond individual insights, Facet5 is an unparalleled tool for building high-performing leadership teams. By fostering a shared language around personality and behavior, it enables leaders to better understand and leverage the diverse talents within their teams. This alignment is crucial for driving cohesive strategy and fostering a culture of collaboration.
One European CEO who implemented Facet5 for her leadership team described the results as transformative: “Facet5 didn’t just help us understand each other better; it gave us the tools to operate as a unified force. We moved from working as individual experts to functioning as a truly cohesive team.”
The Leadership Edge
Leadership today is as much about adaptability and empathy as it is about vision and strategy. Facet5 equips senior leaders with the clarity and confidence to lead with authenticity, empowering them to navigate uncertainty while inspiring their teams.
In a world where leadership is often reduced to buzzwords and quick fixes, Facet5 stands out as a tool of substance. It doesn’t just analyze personality—it unlocks potential, builds resilience, and transforms how leaders see themselves and their teams.
As organizations across Europe, North America, and Canada continue to face rapid change, those who invest in tools like Facet5 are better positioned to thrive. After all, great leadership starts with self-awareness—and there’s no better tool to ignite that journey than Facet5.
To quote a senior HR executive who has deployed Facet5 across multiple markets:
“Facet5 isn’t just a tool; it’s an investment in leadership excellence. It turns insights into action, and action into transformation.”
Ready to discover the transformative power of Facet5 for your leadership? The journey starts with self-awareness—and Facet5 is the key to unlocking it.

The session had three main parts: we started with a review of crisis management principles in accordance with ISO 22361 Security and resilience – Crisis management – Guidelines. We then conducted a guided warm up exercise and moved immediately into an in-depth international hostage scenario. This hostage taking location was defined by the client so that it would be a very realistic exercise.

Read More »
Vets Without Borders in Africa

Veterinarians Without Borders: Crisis Management Team Training

Preparing for this engagement presented the team with some good challenges including a very globally dispersed work/volunteer force within this not-for-profit organization. At each location there is a mix of locally employed persons and expats with corporate leadership in Canada.

The session had three main parts: we started with a review of crisis management principles in accordance with ISO 22361 Security and resilience – Crisis management – Guidelines. We then conducted a guided warm up exercise and moved immediately into an in-depth international hostage scenario. This hostage taking location was defined by the client so that it would be a very realistic exercise.

Read More »
strategic retreat

Case Study – Autumn 2024 – A Strategic Retreat with RCAS and Concert Infrastructure

‘In pursuit of team high performance’

Working with the leadership team at Concert Infrastructure, RCAS designed and delivered a high-impact strategic retreat that weaved leadership behaviors, a powerful sense of team ethos, and increased cultural awareness into business-critical activities.

Concert Infrastructure lead an aggregate portfolio capitalization of more than $3.4 billion, specializing in direct investment and management of high-profile public-private partnership projects across Canada.

Rooted in four distinct pillars of high-performing teams, RCAS built a series of activities, guided discussion principles, and points of reflections that stimulated new ways of thinking and ‘flushed out self-challenges’ that would move this long-standing executive team from good to great.

Read More »
leadership for the future

An exciting day for RCAS and the future of leadership training!!!!​

I recently posted about our leadership offering BRIGHT FUTURE and more specifically, exciting new additions to team RCAS. James and I constantly preach that your crisis or executive management team needs to diverse in thought & action if you want to have any chance of successfully navigating today’s perma-crisis business environment.

James and I are very proud and excited to announce that Samantha Woolven and Kate Forrest have joined RCAS. To say they bring a wealth of knowledge and experience in leadership and human performance would be a gross understatement. They have successfully transformed senior leaders and teams across the following industries: architecture, botanical gardens + science, automotive manufacturing, charities/NGO, construction, defence, energy, engineering, food & beverage, heavy metal refining, mining, mining rehabilitation, cultural institutions, nuclear, petrochemical, pharmaceutical, private equity, health care, rail transport, supermarkets and retail. Might have been easier to list what industries they haven’t supported (yet 😉).

We have had the pleasure of collaborating with these exceptional ladies over the last few years, learning a ton in the process about delivering curated professional leadership experiences. I wish I could share a “fly on the wall” video with you of our BRIGHT FUTURE program planning sessions. What I can say is they are exciting, vibrant and full of ideas on how to develop unique leadership experiences for our clients.

Very shortly, James, who spearheads our leadership practice, will be releasing more details about our BRIGHT FUTURE offering. If you have any questions or comments, please reach out directly to James at [email protected].

Read More »

Need Advice?